May 19, 2021


Beyond law

Ex-protection main for subsidiary of Hudbay Minerals pleads guilty to killing, paralyzing Indigenous Guatemalans

On Wednesday, the former head of security for a subsidiary of the Toronto-based mining business Hudbay Minerals officially pled guilty in a Guatemalan courtroom to killing a regional Indigenous local community leader and paralyzing yet another Indigenous guy.

This could have important ramifications for two lawsuits in opposition to Hudbay underway in Ontario that centre on the Sept. 27, 2009, killing and maiming of the Indigenous adult males.

Mynor Padilla, the previous security main of CGN, a Guatemalan nickel-mining firm that was owned by Hudbay in between 2008 and 2011, pled guilty to the crimes on Dec. 17, 2020, as component of an settlement struck in between Padilla and his victims, amongst them Angelica Choc, the widow of slain neighborhood leader Adolfo Ich, and German Chub, who was paralyzed.

On Wednesday, the court docket acknowledged and ratified the guilty pleas.

The court’s choice could be match-transforming for two lawsuits that Choc and Chub released from Hudbay in Ontario in 2010. They allege that Hudbay was negligent in how it managed the non-public security of its subsidiary, CGN, which has a compound located close to numerous Indigenous communities in rural Guatemala.

In paperwork submitted in courtroom, Padilla is alleged to have shot Ich in the head at close vary following Ich was dragged by way of the fence of CGN’s compound by security guards and experienced his arm just about severed by a machete blow.

Padilla is also alleged to have shot Chub at shut selection, paralyzing him from the mid-chest down and forever collapsing his left lung, as Chub viewed a community soccer game close to CGN. Neither male posed a danger to CGN safety.

The court’s choice is significant due to the fact just one of Hudbay’s main authorized defences is that Padilla did not shoot both man. In actuality, Hudbay has said in court that Choc and Chub have “concocted” tales falsely accusing Padilla of the violence he has now pled responsible to owning fully commited.

Wednesday’s ruling “pulls the rug out from underneath Hudbay’s essential defence,” reported Cory Wanless, 1 of the lawyers symbolizing Choc and Chub in their lawsuits towards Hudbay.

“Mr. Padilla’s felony proceedings are coming to a summary based mostly on a plea arrangement, which accounts for numerous distinctive factors,” Hudbay reported in an electronic mail. “We will critique the court’s prepared determination at the time it is produced. Any agreements produced in the Guatemalan court do not influence our perspective of the points or Hudbay’s liability in relation to civil matters at this time before the Ontario court docket.”

CGN did not reply to requests for remark. Padilla could not be achieved for comment.

The guilty pleas do not quickly invalidate Hudbay’s argument that Padilla did not kill Ich and paralyze Chub, but Ontario courts will take into account them “highly relevant and hugely persuasive” pieces of proof that “will grow to be a important part” of the lawsuits if they go to demo, stated Murray Klippenstein, another lawyer for Choc and Chub.

Hudbay will now have to depend greatly on the other pillar of its authorized defence, which is that it was not negligent in its administration of CGN’s non-public security, Klippenstein and Wanless mentioned. The two lawyers will argue versus that defence by drawing on hundreds of the additional than 20,000 inside company files disclosed by Hudbay as a result of the discovery process. The documents paint “a extremely thorough image of the specifics surrounding” the shootings of Ich and Chub, Klippenstein said.

“Based on what we know, it is likely to be quite tough for Hudbay to argue that they really don’t bear accountability for what took place at their mine,” Wanless said. “The higher-ups at Hudbay were effectively conscious of what occurred on the ground in Guatemala.”

Padilla was sentenced by the Guatemalan court to a whole of two decades and 8 months for his crimes from Ich and Chub. The court docket has commuted his sentence to fines that are to be paid to the courtroom. Padilla also formerly paid Chub and Choc in out-of-court docket settlements. On Wednesday, the court also recognized his responsible pleas for assaulting two other Indigenous villagers on the exact same day. The terms of his sentence were being agreed on by Padilla and his victims in advance of the court docket recognized them.

Padilla previously put in about 4.5 decades in jail awaiting an before trial for these crimes that finished in an acquittal, but that acquittal was overturned on appeal amidst allegations of corruption towards the choose who presided about it.

Reactions to the plea offer have been mixed. Klippenstein and Wanless viewed as it to be a comparatively good outcome in gentle of the dysfunctionality of Guatemala’s justice technique and the impunity rampant inside of the state. But Ramon Cadena, a Guatemalan human rights law firm and regional director for the Global Fee of Jurists, said that the sentence was just a slap on the wrist. “It is a reflection of the impunity in Guatemala,” he said.



“It’s not really reasonable, but for me, on the other hand, it is a big achievement,” claimed Angelica Choc.

She choked up. “It hurts me as well a lot … remembering my husband.” But now, with the guilty plea coming far more than a 10 years just after her husband’s dying, “I really feel really at peace.”